Perfect chocolate-oatmeal cookie is a childhood dream
From
Beverly Mills
| August 12, 2009
In Coffee and Convo, Kitchen Basics
Featured Recipe: Chocolate-Peanut Butter No-Bake Cookies
Lalena Price of Charleston, W.Va., was desperate. “All I want is that simple recipe for no-bake chocolate oatmeal cookies – you know, the kind the elementary school cooks make with oats, peanut butter, cocoa and such. I can find it nowhere.”
My elementary school cafeteria also served these cookies, and so did my Mom. Once I even found them for sale at a gas station along a country road just off the Interstate. When we published the recipe in our column years ago in response to Lalena’s plea, I even got fan mail from a state penitentiary.
“I just wanted you to know I’ve been making your chocolate-peanut butter oatmeal cookies, and everyone here is crazy about them,” said an inmate who worked in the kitchen. “Thanks for the recipe.”
Sadly since the cookies contain peanut butter, today’s elementary tykes (and inmates?) may never experience this treat en masse. Peanut allergy is a real problem, I know, but that doesn’t stop me from mourning the fact that kids will never get to love these cookies unless parents of the un-allergic everywhere unite and make them.
This cookie is a one-pot wonder -- a bit like fudge only with oatmeal. Gotta love it, right?! So did anyone else out there grow up with this cookie?
Comments
From Beverly Mills - August 13, 2009
I am sitting here with my son Sam who's home from college. He sees the blog photo: "Ummm....you've got to make some of those. Very soon." So guess what I'll be doing ....very soon!
From Diane - August 14, 2009
When I make No-Bakes (also known as Mississippi Mud Cookies at my house,) I use crunchy peanut butter sometimes. It gives an extra bit of texture. A batch won't even last a day here! Diane
From julianna aston - August 14, 2009
I'd guess that you are not cooking/boiling them long enough. Also, if you cook them on a rainy day, they absorb moisture and will not set up right. Make them on a sunny day.<a href="http://www.diningsetdirect.com/products/Dining-Room-Furniture/Dining-Chairs/Dining-Chairs_1_1.html">Dining Chair</a>
From Beverly Mills - August 18, 2009
Hi Julianna....it's very true that the cooking time on these cookies can be a bit tricky. If you boil too long, the cookies will firm up too quickly and sort of be crumbly and not shiny. If you don't boil long enough, they'll never fully firm up. And it's also very true that the "ambient" conditions of humidity and temperature make a difference in how long to boil and how long they need to stand to firm. I tried once to get the exact temperature on a candy thermometer so the recipe could be standardized, and I think it's somewhere just below a soft ball stage, but was never able to stick with the process long enough to get it nailed. What happened? I ate so many of them that I was starting to need to go shopping for larger trousers! Has anyone ever seen a recipe with a temperature on it?
From Cuisinart Breadmakers - August 28, 2009
here is the recipe MISSOURI COOKIES 1 c. sugar 1 1/2 tsp. cocoa or 1 sq. baking chocolate 1/4 c. real butter 1/4 c. milk 1 tbsp. molasses 1/4 tsp. vanilla 1/4 c. peanut butter 1 1/2 c. quick cooking oatmeal Mix sugar, cocoa, butter, and milk in heavy skillet on top of range. Heat until bubbly. Add vanilla, peanut butter, and oatmeal; mix well. Drop on waxed paper by the spoonful. Let cool. <a href="http://www.zimbio.com/panasonicbreadmaker2/articles/0T99YHDfJjn/Unique+Characteristics+Cuisinart+Bread+Maker">Cuisinart Breadmakers</a>
Related Recipes
Chocolate-Peanut Butter No-Bake Cookies
August 05, 2009
Lalena Price was desperate. “All I want is that simple recipe for no-bake chocolate oatmeal cookies – you know, the kind with oats, peanut butter, and cocoa." Here it is!
Read full recipe.My Books
Our Cookbooks rock!
What you're saying..
I just had to write to let you both know how much I appreciate your cookbook Desperation Dinners! I bought it about a year ago, and you should see it. It’s in bad shape – splattered, stained, dog-eared and well-used. I’ve bought a lot of cookbooks, and at most, I get one recipe out of it, and then it sits on the shelf.
Your cookbook is really different. I actually use it. I use your cookbook so much, and have sung it’s praises so often, that now whenever I put a good meal on the table, my husband automatically asks, “Is this a Desperation Dinner?
Rebecca Clarke
Montgomery, Ala.
Have a question?
We hope you'll tell us, but we hope you'll ASK us, too! Send your questions to alicia@kitchenscoop.com and we'll try to find the answers.
From daysgoby - August 12, 2009
Actually, no. But my husband did - his aunt made me some the week after we were married and made all this silly-in-law stuff ALL BETTER. And they're called mudpies here. I'm not sure if that's just a Canadian thing or not. But YUM.